Synchro Duel Academy
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


The Academy of the Future!
 
HomePortalSearchLatest imagesRegisterLog in
Log in
Username:
Password:
Log in automatically: 
:: I forgot my password
Similar topics
    Top posters
    vem123
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Winduct
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    redgar
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    sinakis
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Terraplant
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    IversonSt3
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Stef
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    NoobSlayer13
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Chaos714
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Harper7000
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_lcapProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_voting_barProtector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse I_vote_rcap 
    Latest topics
    » Chatbox
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by IDK Fri Sep 12, 2014 2:50 pm

    » Harp
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by IDK Fri Sep 12, 2014 2:47 pm

    » AGAIN HELLO!
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by Blazenjaden5 Tue Apr 09, 2013 12:53 am

    » Archlord Kristya(Sychron's worst nightmare)
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by CrimsonClimax Fri Aug 10, 2012 4:31 pm

    » HELLO
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by CrimsonClimax Fri Aug 10, 2012 12:27 pm

    » Number 91: Thunder Spark Dragon
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by Chaos714 Sun May 27, 2012 2:14 am

    » Card of the Week #49
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by xemnas night Sat May 26, 2012 8:31 am

    » PM.
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1by sinakis Tue May 22, 2012 12:52 pm

    Affiliates

     

     Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse

    Go down 
    4 posters
    AuthorMessage
    sinakis
    Ancient Administrator
    Ancient Administrator
    sinakis


    Posts : 846
    Join date : 2010-06-02
    Location : SPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACE

    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1Thu Jan 06, 2011 9:25 am

    Protector of the Sanctuary
    Spoiler:

    Psi-Impulse
    Spoiler:

    So. There's supposed to be a rulling ( that I can't officialy find anywhere ) that you and your opponent cannot activate a card that forces player A to draw cards, if player B controls a face-up Protector.
    Outside of the draw-phase of course.

    I also read that a Flip Effect monster that forces player A to draw can be activated, an example being Morphing Jar.

    According to that, Psi-Impulse cannot be activated.

    Then why ygo-wikia has
    Quote :
    Use this card while "Protector of the Sanctuary" is in control to stop your opponent from drawing 3 cards.
    in "Psi-Impulse" 's tip page?

    Guess we can't trust the wikia that much, can we?

    ( The final question is not about wikia, but about "Protector". )

    A final note:
    If neither player controls a Protector, and player A activates Psi-Impulse and then chains Call of the Haunted to special summon Protector, the effect will get through and player B won't get to draw cards...right?
    Back to top Go down
    e^ipi+1=0
    Amateur
    Amateur
    e^ipi+1=0


    Posts : 128
    Join date : 2010-11-11

    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Re: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1Thu Jan 06, 2011 10:55 am

    any1 can edit wikia(especially the tips, ruling is less abused, since you need to also put a trustworthy source), that's mostly the reason, though, as the time passes, their admin will remove any incorrect statement.

    similar with allure of darkness and imperial iron wall
    if Protector of the Sanctuary is summoned (for example via call of the haunted) in the same chainlink after card like psi-impulse is activated, then your opponent will not draw.

    though,even hand destruction, and call of the haunted is actually enough to pull that trick.
    Back to top Go down
    Supreme_King
    Intermediate
    Intermediate
    Supreme_King


    Posts : 162
    Join date : 2010-11-19
    Location : Romania

    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Re: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1Thu Jan 06, 2011 11:56 am

    If you have the option to activate or not an effect that would cause your opponent to draw cards, then you can't activate it. If the effect activates because of gameplay mechanics, such as Morphing Jar being flipped, then it carries out without your opponent drawing.

    As DarkMatter said, wikia tips aren't trustworthy, just use common sense and, if that isn't enough to solve the issue, ask some guys who are advanced in rulings so they can explain why or why not something can happen.
    Back to top Go down
    Stef
    Administrator
    Administrator
    Stef


    Posts : 660
    Join date : 2010-05-04
    Location : Greece

    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Re: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:54 pm

    Like DarkMatter said, anyone can edit the wikia, and we don't have a bunch of elves that check every page every single day for mistakes, so there is obviously a chance that there will be some wrong suggestions/tips sometimes.

    According to Protector's rulings, the tip is incorrect, except if you chain Call of the Haunted to Psi-Impulse.

    IMO, I believe that it was just an incorrect tip.
    Back to top Go down
    sinakis
    Ancient Administrator
    Ancient Administrator
    sinakis


    Posts : 846
    Join date : 2010-06-02
    Location : SPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACE

    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Re: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1Thu Jan 06, 2011 11:13 pm

    Thank you :)
    Yes any card that makes player A draw cards would be the same (I mean if it's activation is optional), I just mentioned Psi-Impulse because I randomly - and falsely - thought that the cost has something to do with that tip.
    I'll edit that out.

    Also, I gave Supreme_King a +1 because his answer was exactly what i wanted to learn. :)

    Solved and Locked!~
    Back to top Go down
    Sponsored content





    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Empty
    PostSubject: Re: Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse   Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse Icon_minitime1

    Back to top Go down
     
    Protector of the Sanctuary VS Psi-Impulse
    Back to top 
    Page 1 of 1
     Similar topics
    -
    » Protector of the Founders, Tyrus

    Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
    Synchro Duel Academy :: Yu-Gi-Oh TCG :: Questions-
    Jump to: